ALBUQUERQUE

Legal experts weighed in Monday on the current state and possible future of New Mexico’s public records law, with lawmakers expected to consider changes in the upcoming legislative session.

Attorneys and open records advocates spoke about what may be next for the sunshine law after a state Department of Justice-led task force spent much of the summer scrutinizing it.

The remarks came at the Inspection of Public Records Act Symposium held by the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government at the State Bar of New Mexico. The annual event serves as both an opportunity for continuing legal education for attorneys and a fundraiser for the foundation, which regularly files lawsuits for alleged IPRA violations and operates a hotline for members of the public who have questions about the law or its implementation.

The IPRA Task Force submitted a final version of its report recommending changes to the law — compiled after a statewide tour soliciting feedback — to state legislators last month. The law was established in its modern form in 1993.

The recommendations included creating a public-facing portal for traffic accident reports and charging out-of-state requestors for police body camera footage.

“I think, as we go into this spring, the Legislature may act on some of the recommendations,” said Kenneth Stalter, a civil rights and personal injury attorney who presented at the symposium and was a member of the IPRA Task Force. “… I think it’s worth taking a little bit of time to look at the tenor of the comments and the context of the comments.”

Stalter pointed to a common theme he noticed in the public comments made by records custodians and government officials throughout the “listening tour,” which stretched from April to August, noting a lot of people are unhappy with how the system currently works.

“What’s fascinating is that the unhappiness is almost diametrically opposed between custodians and requestors,” Stalter said. “Requestors are unhappy about certain things and custodians are unhappy about certain things, and their complaints are very, very different.”

While requestors were concerned about their asks for records being denied in ways they thought were improper, custodians felt overwhelmed by surging requests, unable to do their jobs well and afraid of liability, he said.

Some custodians described IPRA as a “weapon” wielded by requestors for financial gain or other purposes.

“I want to give both sides a fair shake in this debate,” Stalter said. “I also think it’s important, even for those of us who are on the transparency side and do not want to see significant changes to IPRA, to understand that these are the points that are being raised in the debate.”

Earlier in the day, former New Mexico Corrections Department attorney David Pardo showcased his research on increased staffing as a way to improve IPRA’s functionality. The New Mexico Corrections Department faces multiple lawsuits over alleged violations of IPRA. Pardo filed his own whistleblower lawsuit against the agency last month, alleging he was retaliated against when he tried to address problems related to its provision of public records.

“When requests climb steadily across the board, agencies … are automatically accumulating statutory violations every single day a request sits unfulfilled,” Pardo said. “Consequently, without adequate staffing, the right technology … delays and backlogs will surge.”

His research, compiled in a report titled “From Access to Capacity: Embedding Staffing Duties in the Inspection of Public Records Act” and developed through his own IPRA requests was published over the summer in The Bar Bulletin.

IPRA requires custodians to allow for the inspection of public records immediately or “as soon as practicable,” but no later than 15 calendar days after the they received a request. Exceptions are allowed for requests deemed “excessively burdensome or broad,” which custodians can take a “reasonable” additional period of time to respond to.

But sometimes that period stretches months.

While state agencies like the Corrections Department have employees whose sole job is to be a records custodian, some smaller municipalities or local governments do not, meaning the responsibility can fall on a clerk, for example.

Pardo said he hopes the Legislature considers embedding minimum record custodian staffing ratios into IPRA.

Monday’s symposium also included a panel with current and former state Supreme Court justices, who outlined the process and logic that led to a May ruling in a decadelong public records case over a report on a former Albuquerque Public Schools superintendent.

The ruling in Albuquerque Journal, et al. v. Board of Education of Albuquerque Public Schools, et al. clarified the scope of an exception to IPRA that protects “matters of opinion” from disclosure. That exception, justices held, does not mean government entities can withhold entire records because some “matters of opinion” exist within them.

Public records stickers lay on a desk for people attending the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government’s Annual IPRA Symposium at the State Bar of New Mexico in Albuquerque on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026.
Gabriela Campos/The New Mexican

“That was our starting point of the analysis: Democratic system of government requires an informed citizen,” Justice Briana H. Zamora said. “And the only way we can self-govern is if we have access to information, and that the right to know is really the rule and non-disclosure is the exception.”

Lily Alexander is a state accountability reporter for The New Mexican and Searchlight New Mexico, focusing on equity and transparency. Her position is part of the New Mexican Public Service Journalism Fund, and her stories are available to all readers without a paywall.

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a comment