A butterfly tattoo helped identify the body of 30-year-old Laura McNaughton in 2005.
Blood on the running board of a pickup helped identify the man who was ultimately charged with and convicted of her murder, Clovis dentist James Smith, who is still serving out a prison sentence of life plus 27 years.
The story hit television screens nationwide Friday night on NBC’s popular long-running series Dateline. The two-hour episode, titled “Hunters,” delves into McNaughton’s case through interviews with her family members and the law enforcement personnel who investigated it.
“This one was disturbing right off the bat,” journalist Blayne Alexander tells former Curry County Sheriff’s Office criminal investigator David Loera in the episode.

Courtesy photo
“It was a young lady,” he replies. “She was displayed, almost … her hair was slicked back like she had just got out of the shower.”
A group of hunters found McNaughton’s body in a culvert along a rural road in Curry County in December 2005. A Clovis resident and mother to two daughters, McNaughton worked as a waitress at the RibCrib while attending community college with the dream of becoming a teacher, the Albuquerque Journal reported at the time.
“Laura was a wonderful woman who loved her children and touched the hearts of those she came in contact with,” her obituary read.
Smith, then 36 and a married father of two, was arrested Dec. 20, 2005, on suspicion of strangling McNaughton. He was a regular patron of the RibCrib, The Associated Press reported at the time, and an arrest warrant affidavit stated he sought out McNaughton when she was working and gave her large tips.

Courtesy photo
Investigators seized DVD movies from Smith’s dental offices in Portales depicting the “strangulation of females” and “homicide of females,” according to the arrest warrant affidavit.
Under a plea deal that did not include an acknowledgement of guilt, Smith was sentenced to at least 57 years in prison, meaning he won’t see the possibility of parole until 2063.
Dateline can be viewed 24/7 through numerous streaming services, including Peacock, Roku and YouTube.
Lily Alexander is a state accountability reporter for The New Mexican and Searchlight New Mexico, focusing on equity and transparency. Her position is part of the New Mexican Public Service Journalism Fund, and her stories are available to all readers without a paywall.

