Santa Fe resident Edgar Chacon-Miranda has in recent years handled his immigration to the U.S. from Guatemala in what many call the “right way.”

He has nonimmigrant status through a U visa, a legal protection afforded to crime victims who cooperate with law enforcement, and he has made a habit of carrying around a batch of records that prove it.

Still, one morning last month, Chacon-Miranda found himself handcuffed in the parking lot of a Santa Fe medical clinic, separated from his young daughter and jailed for more than three weeks.

He is one of an increasing number of foreign nationals with legal status who have been arrested and detained as part of a sweeping, nationwide federal immigration enforcement effort.

After 23 days in the Torrance County Detention Facility in Estancia, 45-year-old Chacon-Miranda and his attorneys say there is limited recourse for those in his situation — what they allege was a wrongful arrest by immigration agents, followed by what appear to be fabrications in reports, and even in sworn court records, to justify detaining a man with legal status.

Chacon-Miranda, freed earlier this month, decried what he and his attorneys call an unlawful arrest.

“All I want is to clear my name,” he said in an interview last week. “There are so many people who’ve seen so many things about me that aren’t true.”

Jaylah Areli Chacon, 13, spins her sister, Dora Elisa Chacon, 2, while Emilia Aleysha Chacon, 11, watches on Saturday in their home on the south side of Santa Fe. Their father, Edgar Chacon-Miranda, was arrested by ICE agents last month and placed in a detention center for more than three works, despite having legal status and no criminal convictions.
Nathan Burton/The New Mexican

He became the local face of the federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement crackdown in Santa Fe following his high-profile arrest, alongside his daughter, outside a La Familia Health clinic, an incident captured on video and widely shared on social media. The immigrant arrest was one of what advocates say were at least 15 in Santa Fe County in August.

People on both sides of the immigration debate seized on the incident, with Republicans referring to Chacon-Miranda as one of the “criminal illegal aliens” the crackdown is meant to target.

But he hasn’t been convicted of a crime, and he has legal status to be in the U.S.

‘It wasn’t his car’

Chacon-Miranda’s arrest involved a case of mistaken identity.

He was driving near the intersection of Agua Fría Street and Caja del Oro when ICE agents began surveilling him, according to a report from the federal agency. The agents ran the license plate number on his vehicle through a law enforcement database, the report said, and found it was registered to Edgar Chacon-Miranda.

That’s not possible, Chacon-Miranda and his attorneys have said.

He had been driving a vehicle registered to his brother that day, and when ICE agents approached him in the La Familia Medical Center parking lot, after following him across town, they believed he was his brother, he said.

Even after he had been detained and taken to ICE’s Albuquerque field office, he said, the agents still believed he was lying about his identity.

The report from ICE makes no mention of agents arresting Chacon-Miranda based on a misconception, however.

Court records show Chacon-Miranda provided the current registration for the vehicle he was driving, a 2023 Toyota registered to his brother. Nonetheless, ICE Deportation Officer Matthew Salcido repeated the false claim about the license plate check in a sworn declaration filed in federal court Sept. 18, writing the number was tied to Chacon-Miranda.

“That’s not true because it wasn’t his car,” said Allegra Love, one of his attorneys. “They didn’t know who they were arresting.”

Officials from the agency did not respond to emailed questions about the case Friday.

One of the agents present during Chacon-Miranda’s arrest was Adriana Torres, an ICE officer who has been accused of drunken driving in Albuquerque and has continued to work in the field, arresting people throughout Northern New Mexico, while her own criminal case is pending.

Torres’ attorney has fought aggressively against her DWI charge, arguing her arrest in late 2024 came during a pretextual stop and was “unconstitutional.”

Chacon-Miranda told the ICE officers about his U visa status, he said. He handed over proof of the visa, his Social Security card and even documents showing he had paid taxes in New Mexico.

“I told him, ‘Everything is right here. … The receipts prove I’m legally in this country,’ ” he said.

U visa protections

An officer who accused Chacon-Miranda of lying about his identity threatened to reinstate a past deportation order.

“He told me, ‘You were deported in 2010, and I’m going to deport you again. You have to sign here,’ ” Chacon-Miranda said, noting an agent pushed him to sign a removal order.

He refused to sign the document, however, and was sent to Torrance County Detention Facility, one of the three immigrant detention centers in the state.

Chacon-Miranda had been deported in 2010 in accordance with a removal order after he was arrested by U.S. Border Patrol officers the previous year. During his recent detention, officers issued a notice of intent to reinstate the 2010 deportation order.

Chacon-Miranda’s attorneys filed a habeas corpus lawsuit Aug. 28, challenging his detention and seeking his release. The case argues his U visa from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services nullifies the past violations.

“In granting any relief under the U visa program, USCIS makes certain findings and waives inadmissibility grounds, thereby allowing the admission of a nonimmigrant to reside in the United States,” his lawsuit states. “Only USCIS, not ICE, can revoke an approved petition for U nonimmigrant status.”

He had received his U visa in 2022 after cooperating with the Santa Fe Police Department on an incident in 2015 in which he alleges he was robbed, threatened and beaten upon returning home from work in the early hours of the morning.

Chacon-Miranda noted he had called police despite his assailant’s threat that his family would be targeted if he notified law enforcement.

His U visa would have expired this year. However, his lawyers note in legal filings that because he filed an application for lawful permanent residency in 2025, the U visa protections are set to be renewed until immigration authorities issue a decision on his pending application.

Without Chacon-Miranda and his attorneys’ knowledge, the federal authorities had determined he was protected from deportation, even before they filed the habeas case.

Salcido wrote in a sworn affidavit that on Aug. 24, five days after the arrest, ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations “submitted a release request to headquarters.”

The request was approved Sept. 10, Salcido wrote, and Chacon-Miranda was released the following day.

The dismissed charges

An ICE spokesperson had confirmed Chacon-Miranda was the father arrested Aug. 19 outside La Familia Medical Center, calling him a “criminal illegal alien,” and listing an “extensive criminal history,” including child abuse and criminal sexual penetration — charges that had been dropped after a 2018 case against him was dismissed.

“Under President Trump and [Homeland Security] Secretary [Markwayne] Mullin, ICE is targeting the worst of the worst,” the spokesperson wrote in an email shortly after the arrest.

New Mexico Republicans ran with the claims, issuing a news release including a Santa Fe police officer’s statement of probable cause for the incident.

“Democrats have plenty of outrage for ICE, but apparently very little for the people this man was accused of harming,” House Republican Whip Alan Martinez of Rio Rancho said in a statement. “The fact that they are publicly defending him should concern every New Mexican.”

Chacon-Miranda’s spouse at the time had told police he forced himself on her while she was lying in bed with their two daughters. When she rejected his advances, she told police, Chacon-Miranda grew “agitated,” and shook her, causing her to hit her head multiple times on the headboard.

Chacon-Miranda gave a different account of the story, saying there were no sexual advances during the incident. He alleged the woman had lunged at him and he had shoved her in response. The altercation occurred during an argument over a breakup and his request for her to move out of the house, he said.

Santa Fe police arrested him after the incident. He attended multiple court hearings, he said, while his accuser did not. The case was dismissed after the First Judicial District Attorney’s Office in Santa Fe said the alleged victim did not cooperate with prosecutors.

The two then became engaged in a custody battle over their daughters that ended in joint custody, court records show.

But state District Judge Denise Thomas awarded Chacon-Miranda sole physical custody of his daughters in a May 11 order.

Dora Elisa Chacon, 2, looks through the porch railing at her home while her father, Edgar Chacon-Miranda and sister Emilia Aleysha Chacon look on, on Saturday in Santa Fe.
Nathan Burton/The New Mexican

ICE accountability?

Chacon-Miranda was one of thousands of people arrested in recent months during what has been referred to as a “quiet surge” of summer immigration enforcement across the country, reflected by a record numbers of immigration-related arrests.

ICE agents arrested almost 51,000 people nationwide in August, surpassing the all-time record for arrests set in the previous two months, according to a news release from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

An analysis by Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse in July found that more than 70% of people held in ICE custody as of July had no criminal conviction.

Arrests of people with legal status, like Chacon-Miranda, have become common, immigration attorneys say.

Rebecca Sheff, a senior staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union of New Mexico, said the mechanisms for holding ICE agents accountable for misconduct — such as lying on official paperwork — are “very, very limited.”

“It’s very different than what’s available for local police or state personnel, and that’s a serious challenge,” Sheff said. “In terms of accountability and in terms of deterring ICE from acting unlawfully, from violating people’s rights, from throwing people in detention for no reason whatsoever — it’s really challenging.”

She pointed to a 1971 federal case known as Bivens that has provided a vehicle to sue federal officers for violating constitutional rights, but she noted the Bivens doctrine has been narrowed in recent decades to the point at which it is now “practically nonexistent.”

Another option is the Federal Tort Claims Act, which allows for people to sue the government as a whole, as opposed to individual officers. But the only remedy available is money.

“You can’t get an injunction prohibiting them from engaging in this type of behavior going forward, and you can’t get other types of remedies for their past harm,” Sheff said. “It’s just about money, and it takes forever.”

She noted a habeas corpus case, like Chacon-Miranda’s attorneys filed, is an action focused on whether a person should be detained — not to hold ICE officers accountable.

His attorneys filed a motion Friday seeking further procedural protections for him that should prevent him from being arrested by ICE agents again.

Chacon-Miranda wasn’t mistreated at the Torrance center, a facility that has seen myriad reports of poor conditions, including sewage entering living areas, Chacon-Miranda said.

Still, he recalled three weeks of “torment.”

“They lock us in a tiny room where there are two of us … and every so often they’re taking us out, shoving us back in, then out again.”

Worse than the conditions: seeing his daughters cry during their multiple visits, he said.

“It’s something I wouldn’t wish on anyone,” Chacon-Miranda said. “… Because you can be strong, but your family can’t.”

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a comment