New Mexico teachers union officials and education advocates decried Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s decision earlier this month to opt in a federal school choice tax credit program during a Tuesday morning news conference in Santa Fe.

The program, which was created in President Donald Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act and is referred to as the Education Freedom Tax Credit, gives taxpayers a credit on their federal taxes for donations to nonprofit “scholarship granting organizations.” Those organizations then give students scholarships for tuition, fees, supplies and other services at public, private, religious or charter schools.

Lujan Grisham’s decision to participate in the program drew immediate backlash from public school advocates and teachers unions, which continued with Tuesday’s news conference.

The state’s teachers unions and advocates, referring to the program as a “voucher scheme,” have argued it will pull resources away from the state’s public education system, crippling it for those who rely on neighborhood schools.

National Education Association of New Mexico president Bethany Jarrell said the program is “designed to use the tax code to subsidize private education expenses through privately operated scholarship granting organizations.”

“They do not have the constitutional responsibility to educate every child. They are not required to serve every student who needs an education. They do not carry the same obligations to students with disabilities, English learners or children who need additional services and support. They can distribute scholarships to some, but they cannot guarantee an equitable education for all,” she said.

Lujan Grisham became the third Democratic governor to opt into the program, reversing a position she took against it in January.

On Tuesday, Governor’s Office spokesperson Michael Coleman wrote in an email that Lujan Grisham believes the state “must secure every dollar it can to improve public education and build on New Mexico’s progress in literacy and student achievement,” particularly in the face of what he described as plummeting federal investments in education.

Coleman added that the tax credit is open to public school students, and Lujan Grisham is working to ensure those kids benefit from it.

“Governor Lujan Grisham is fully aware that Republicans in Congress have pushed for school vouchers for a very long time, and she disagrees with that approach. She would have preferred more direct federal investment in public education in lieu of this tax credit,” Coleman wrote. “But the reality is she had to choose whether to opt-in and allow donations to flow to public and private school students in New Mexico or opt-out and allow donors in New Mexico and elsewhere who claim the tax credit to send their money to other states.”

He added, “Given those limited choices, Governor Lujan Grisham decided to keep that money in New Mexico where it belongs.”

The state Public Education Department said earlier this month it had reached out to education organizations to discuss the best ways to implement the program to serve students, especially those in need.

There are currently no scholarship granting organizations in New Mexico, department spokesperson Janelle Taylor García said, adding that the state must first launch an application process. It was not yet clear when that would happen, she added, though she said the state would meet its Feb. 15 deadline to submit a list of certified organizations to the federal government.

At Tuesday’s news conference, advocates looked to New Mexico’s future after Lujan Grisham, who is term-limited, leaves office at the end of the year. Deb Haaland, a Democrat and a former U.S. interior secretary, was elected as the next governor earlier this month.

“Gov. Lujan Grisham, there’s still time to reverse your decision, but today I really want to reach out to Gov.-elect Haaland,” said Kris Nordstrom, research director for advocacy organization New Mexico Voices For Children. “You might not be able to reverse the current governor’s decision on this for 2027, but now is the time to loudly and clearly state your intentions to withdraw New Mexico from this program in 2028.”

Hannah Menchhoff, a spokesperson for Haaland, wrote in an email that “the Governor-elect is reviewing the policy, and her top priority will always be providing a quality public education to every child in New Mexico.”

Esteban Candelaria is a corps member with Report for America, a national service program that places journalists into local newsrooms. He covers child welfare and the state Children, Youth and Families Department. Learn more about Report for America at reportforamerica.org.

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a comment