An attorney who seems to have lost a recent bid for president of the Navajo Nation officially filed a grievance late last week alleging violations of the Election Code that, he says, denied voters a free and equal opportunity to select their leaders.

The grievance follows Justin Jones’ request for a vote recount, which was approved Nov. 11 by the Navajo Board of Election Supervisors. Jones and his running mate, Emily Ellison, trail behind Navajo Nation Council Speaker Crystalyne Curley by 1,115 votes in the race, according to unofficial general election results.

The Office of Hearings and Appeals will hold a hearing on Jones’ grievance Thursday. If she remains the winner when the results are certified, Curley will become the first woman to serve as president of the Navajo Nation. The milestone has sparked some controversy on social media, with some voters suggesting dire ramifications — including the end times — if Curley takes office in January, citing beliefs about women being unable to hold top Navajo Nation government positions.

Curley’s supporters, meanwhile, have characterized her win as a moment of pride, fitting with the Navajo Nation’s status as a traditionally matrilineal society.

The Diné Hataałii Association, an organization dedicated to protecting Diné traditions and medicine, called for people to “respect the transition to new leadership” in a statement last week, which Curley posted.

“We are concerned by the rhetoric displayed in the wake of this election,” the statement read. “We must not allow aggression, anger, negative emotions, bad thoughts, and bad words to disrupt the path of our Nation. Our words are sacred, and we must be careful of what we say toward one another.”

Neither Jones’ attorney nor the Board of Election Supervisors answered a phone call Tuesday.

“For too long has our leaders in Window Rock acted as if their actions have no consequences,” Jones said in a statement. “The right to choose our leaders belongs strictly to the Diné people, and every qualified voter deserves an unobstructed, fair opportunity to cast their ballot. When elders are left behind by last-minute social media changes, when families are turned away by floodwaters or empty ballot boxes, and when public resources are used to tip the scales, the integrity of our democracy is compromised.”

Jones’ complaint outlines 10 different allegations, including voter intimidation by “aggressive electioneering within 50-foot boundaries” and disenfranchisement caused by severe flooding blocking access to polls.

The Navajo Nation changed a handful of polling locations the day before the election due to flooding that swept the reservation in October and earlier this month.

Lily Alexander is a state accountability reporter for The New Mexican and Searchlight New Mexico, focusing on equity and transparency. Her position is part of the New Mexican Public Service Journalism Fund, and her stories are available to all readers without a paywall.

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a comment