NAVAJO — The red volcanic mesas, and the pines and sage they watch over along a stretch between Arizona and New Mexico, are what inspired Kim Etsitty to travel to the ends of the Earth.
This summer, that meant the bottom of the ocean. The Diné science teacher joined a crew that scoured unmapped stretches of the Pacific Rim on one of the excursions she takes in her official roles with NASA, National Geographic and the Ocean Exploration Trust.
She has brought the knowledge and experience back to students at Navajo Pine High School, an hour north of Chinle, Ariz., where she grew up. She has been proud to use her partnerships with the scientific community to merge contemporary nautical and astronomical understanding with the ancestral knowledge of the land Navajo people have developed over centuries.
But Etsitty and other Native American teachers say they are being pushed out by officials at Gallup-McKinley County Schools, the most Navajo school district in the nation. Some say nearly three dozen employees have left in the last year.
They say the district — mired in recent years by federal, state and tribal investigations into allegations of retaliation and discrimination against teachers and students, reports on inequities and “troubling practices,” lawsuits and ethics complaints — has continued to come up short in meeting the state’s duty to educate its Native American students.
Rather than celebrate Etsitty’s achievements and opportunities — which often come with full financial support from science organizations for travel costs and substitute teachers — the district has reprimanded her three times, she said, and has rejected her requests for professional development leave to participate in the field trips.
In one case, she was en route to an expedition when she learned her leave would be denied.
“It’s kind of getting ridiculous to the point where it feels like it’s discrimination,” she said.
Now the only full-time science teacher in Navajo, Etsitty plans to leave before the next school year to lead a charter school across the street from Navajo Pine High School.
‘We don’t always get it right’
Another teacher, Burlene Padilla, said district officials ordered her to end a morning ritual in her sixth grade classroom rooted in Indigenous practices.
Padilla and other teachers also were outraged when the district didn’t observe Oct. 12 as Indigenous Peoples Day, preventing them from participating in tribal activities.
In a district estimated to be 70% to 80% Native American, Padilla wrote in an opinion piece published in The Gallup Sun, “failing to observe Indigenous Peoples’ Day as an official school holiday feels deeply unfair and contradictory.”
Even many non-Navajo staff members say Gallup-McKinley County Schools — with half of its 32 schools on tribal land — is failing to support its teachers and failing to provide the culturally responsive education its students deserve.
District administrators point to an array of initiatives to address concerns, including an equity council. The advisory committee of parents with children from at-risk groups, including Native students, English language learners and students with disabilities, was launched this summer “to help guide district decisions and improve support for students who have historically faced barriers to success in school,” the district said in a statement.
“It’s not always good news, and … we don’t always get it right,” Superintendent Jvanna Hanks said. “But the [school] board needs to be well-informed about what is occurring. I think the equity council is a great way for us to really get good information and feedback.”

‘Keep shooting things down’
Gallup-McKinley County Schools has featured Etsitty in its Elevate Magazine, “kind of like a poster child for them,” she said, “even though behind the scenes I was reprimanded.”
Etsitty has left the classroom for two fellowships: a training forum in Hawaii in spring 2024 and then three weeks aboard a ship off Palau that November, and back-to-back forums in April required by National Geographic and the Ocean Exploration Trust. Both organizations paid for her travel and offered to reimburse the district for substitutes.
Her first expedition was a deep sea exploration aboard the Nautilus, a 223-foot research vessel. She helped map sections of the sea floor across the Pacific Ocean near Palau as part of a small group of fellows sponsored by the nonprofit Ocean Exploration Trust. She returned with the Nautilus to Guam this June, livestreaming the work for students all over the world including those on the Navajo Nation.
Just a month later, she embarked on a trip to the polar ice caps near Iceland as a fellow with the National Geographic Society.
Teachers in the district get only two personal days a year, Etsitty said.
District policy also allows for “approved” professional development leave, but only the superintendent can grant it. Both times, Etsitty asked for professional leave for two trips, and both times the district said no.
Her principal in 2024 approved her leave after getting no answer from the district’s leadership team on the request, but later notified Etsitty as she was traveling to the ship the leave “was not granted.”
The district then reprimanded Etsitty and recorded the absence as leave without pay.
This summer, a new principal said she would have to take personal leave to board the Nautilus again.
Etsitty, who had only a few hours of personal leave remaining, again asked for professional development leave. She also offered to go unpaid. Administrators, including Hanks, said no.
She went anyway. “You’ve given me zero choice but to just leave and represent my community,” Etsitty recalled telling administrators. “And so I did. I just left. … I had no idea if I had a job when I got back.”
She added, “I’m trying and trying and trying, but they keep shooting things down for me. … What I told my principal is that the district has just lost sight of what true education means.”

Nathan Burton/The New Mexican
Showing ‘no dream is too big’
Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren has celebrated Etsitty’s accomplishments, writing, “Kim Etsitty represents the very best of the Navajo Nation. She is showing our young people that no dream is too big and that Diné knowledge and scientific discovery can go hand in hand.”
But Etsitty won’t be bringing her adventures back to Gallup-McKinley County students after the current school year. The district has pushed her to the breaking point, she said.
She plans to join the leadership team of a nearby charter school, the Dził Ditł’ooí School of Empowerment, Action and Perseverance — named for the mountain next to her school.
She had tried to take her students for a short hike on the mountain, but administrators rejected the field trip due to a lack of paperwork. They also rejected a sponsored trip to the Very Large Array in Magdalena, Etsitty said, arguing it was irrelevant to her students’ education.
“I’m too burnt out,” she said.
“These kids are not going to have science taught to them in a way that is going to make their culture stand out and make them proud to be Navajo,” she added, speaking of the district’s students. “It’s gonna be somebody else who’s outside of our community.”
Series of complaints, probes
Few school districts in New Mexico have been plagued with problems like those at Gallup-McKinley County Schools.
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has continued its probe into allegations of discrimination toward Native American job candidates and staff dating to at least 2020.
Former teachers union president Sawyer Masonjones, a non-Navajo teacher, was fired in June 2025 for alleged “gross misconduct.” An arbitrator for the New Mexico Public Employee Labor Relations Board found the district had insufficient cause to terminate him, but the district refused to reinstate him.
The Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission authored a report in late February finding widespread issues, from disparities in discipline to a culture of retaliation.
And a yearslong New Mexico Department of Justice investigation found “troubling disciplinary practices” affecting the district’s Native students, a report states.
Agency spokesperson Lauren Rodriguez said in a recent statement Attorney General Raúl Torrez had met with Hanks “about our findings and to inform the district that we would remain vigilant about ensuring compliance with the law.”
The agency is negotiating an agreement with the state Public Education Department to “formalize data-sharing for districts across the state, which will help us better understand potential discipline inequities,” she added.
Hanks denied there is a culture of racial discrimination in Gallup-McKinley County Schools. In her 24 years in the district, “I have not seen that specific concern brought up from an HR perspective,” she said.
“But do I believe improvement needs to happen? Yes,” she added.
The district’s legal battles have come at a cost. Last year, it spent $513,240 in legal fees for four law firms, according to documents obtained through a public records request.
Former Superintendent Mike Hyatt cost the district far more.
Hyatt, who joined the district as a math teacher in the early 2000s and became superintendent in 2017, moved in May 2025 to terminate a contract with virtual education giant Stride K12 to serve about 3,000 students in a statewide virtual academy based at the district.
Stride alleged in a complaint to the State Ethics Commission that Hyatt had “tried to leverage his position” to get a job with the company and canceled the contract after he was rejected.
The district accused Stride of fraud.
Stride moved its academy to other districts, leaving the state with a potential crisis — under its school funding structure, it was on the hook fund 3,000 students at two districts, at a cost of $75 million.
Lawmakers stopped the double payment but softened the hit on Gallup. Its settlement with Stride is still before an arbitration panel.
Hanks noted the ongoing arbitration restricts her from commenting.

Nathan Burton/The New Mexican
‘The ghost of Hyatt lives on’
Graham McNeill, president of the McKinley County Federation of United School Employees, said 16 teachers and 19 other staff members who have left in the last year are “unlikely to be replaced anytime soon.”
Hanks did not dispute McNeill’s count.
The district had seemed to be turning a new leaf when voters in November 2025 swept three school board incumbents out of office in favor of newcomers promising reforms.
“Unfortunately, the ghost of Hyatt lives on through this new board leadership,” McNeill said at an October board meeting.
The outgoing board chose Hanks, then a deputy superintendent, as Hyatt’s successor, before new board members took their seats. The new board later awarded Hanks a three-year contract at $240,000 a year.
The union, which led the effort to unseat the incumbents, has been largely disappointed with the newcomers’ unwillingness to challenge the administration and to “listen to the community that it’s supposed to be serving,” McNeill said.
School board members did not respond to messages seeking comment on the complaints.
“I’m always gonna have people who criticize,” Hanks said. “That is the nature of the game. But for me, I know every single day I’m working for this district, I’m working for our students because I want it to be successful. I want them to have the future that I know they deserve.”
‘Not afraid to use my voice’
Fears of retaliation dissuaded some staff members from sharing their concerns on the record.
“They retaliate against you here if you say anything,” said Padilla, 44, a sixth grade teacher in Gallup.
She submitted complaints to the Public Education Department and the state Department of Justice, citing a “hostile work environment, severe intimidation, and ongoing administrative retaliation at Lincoln Elementary.”
“This situation has now severely impacted my physical health and mental well-being, leaving me physically sick to my stomach (hospital visit) and deeply concerned for my safety,” she wrote in a complaint.
Neither agency responded to her complaints, she said.
“Nobody is looking in from the outside,” said Padilla, who is Diné. “So they’re thinking that everything and everybody is good.”
Padilla grew up in Gallup and left for Washington state, where she started a family and taught for 23 years. She returned after her husband died last year, to bury him at home.
She has made culturally responsive education her rallying cry.
When she came to the district last year, she brought an evidence-based educational practice she learned in Washington: morning circles, in which she and her students would discuss their lives, what they’re looking forward to and what troubles them. She noted one student spoke about food insecurity, and she was able to get support for the family through the school’s counselor.
A principal told her to stop the practice last year, directing her to be “more honed in on academics,” Padilla said.
Like Etsitty, she’s decided to be more public about what she sees as flaws in the school district.
“I’m not afraid to use my voice,” Etsitty said. “The worst thing [that could happen] is that they let me go.”
André Salkin is an education and immigration reporter for The New Mexican.

