A large permitting reform bill co-sponsored by a New Mexico U.S. senator and stirring debate across the country passed another procedural vote Werdnesday in the U.S. Senate.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act passed a cloture vote 65-31, which ended debate on the proposed package. The cloture vote was the third of three procedural votes on the bill faced Wednesday.
The bill has further votes in the Senate and House and potential amendments ahead of it before it could head to the president’s desk. Wednesday’s cloture vote showed lessened support for the bill from the 73-25 procedural vote on Nov. 9.
The bill, co-sponsored by Democratic U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, seeks to remedy delays in national energy and infrastructure projects. The bill has received wide support from the Citizens Climate Lobby, labor unions, the Solar Energy Industries Association and oil and gas industry leaders. But it has raised concerns over its potential to weaken bedrock environmental protections and historic preservation efforts, and limit public input and tribal consultation.
Heinrich and the other co-sponsors of the bill — Sens. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va.; Mike Lee, R-Utah; and Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I. — say the bill would accelerate green energy projects, lower costs for ratepayers and force data center companies to pay for their connections to electric grids.
Republican U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska called the policy the “most substantive bipartisan agreement on permitting reform” in her time in Congress.
“You can’t do much in Alaska without a federal permit,” she said Wednesday on the Senate floor. “Almost every project that eventually makes it through the process still winds up in court.”
U.S. Sen. Ben Ray Luján, Heinrich’s fellow senator from New Mexico, again voted against bill0 Wednesday. The bill has drawn opposition from other members of New Mexico’s all-Democratic congressional delegation as well.
“There is no question the system is broken and America must rebuild our infrastructure,” New Mexico U.S Rep. Melanie Stansbury said during a House floor proceeding Tuesday. “But that cannot be the building of infrastructure and transmission at any cost.”
A spokesperson for Stansbury said the bill and manager’s amendments are still under debate and negotiation.
“It is unclear what, if any, substantive amendments will be considered and voted on,” Stansbury spokesperson Felecia Pohl wrote in an email. “Once we see the final Senate bill, we will determine the next course of action. At the present time, the base bill and manager’s amendment are actively opposed by Tribal nations, civil rights, and environmental organizations across the country and the Congresswoman cannot support the bill in its current form. “
A spokesperson for U.S. Rep. Teresa Leger Fernández of New Mexico said she too does not support the bill as it stands.
The Rhodium Group, an independent research organization, conducted an analysis of the policy’s potential impacts on the U.S. energy system, electricity prices and greenhouse gas emissions prior to amendments to the bill. Its models found the policy could reduce average electricity bills for residential customers by $50 to $78 a year in 2040. The study also found it could reduce greenhouse gas emissions by between 5 million and 148 million metric tons annually in 2040, and lead to more clean energy projects.
In the hours preceding the vote, some senators argued these positive impacts are not enough.
“Under this bill, big tech gets to build cheaper, faster and without consequence,” U.S. Sen. Ed Markey , D-Mass., said Monday evening. “Communities will be forced to witness the degradation of their land and suffer from more cancer-causing pollution in exchange for the promise of marginal savings, in addition to the $5 a month savings in 15 years, even modelers supporting this bill have found with modest to nonexistent climate and affordability benefits for our country.”
The Center for Western Priorities also pushed back on the Rhodium Group’s findings, saying the analysis did not count “the emissions from the drilling, mining, and gas-powered data centers the bill would lock in on public lands.”

