The Navajo Tribal Utility Authority is pushing to build a data center in San Juan County as part of a sprawling energy and manufacturing campus — a proposal that could go before the full Navajo Nation Council for a vote as soon as next month.

The proposal has been described by proponents and in draft leases as a 599-acre “energy park” that includes solar power generation, battery storage, natural gas-fired turbines, advanced computing, data center “facilities,” and advanced energy manufacturing.

The tribal utility has proposed the project in the tribe’s Nenahnezad Chapter near Fruitland with Lion Point Capital, a New York-based investment firm, and its affiliate, Sunshine Fund, which develops large-scale energy projects. No data center tenant has been selected or signed, Marcus Jacobsson, Sunshine Fund’s CEO, wrote in an email to The New Mexican on behalf of both firms.

He noted the tribal utility authority would be the majority owner of the project, with a 51% stake in the joint venture developing the site and control over the board.

The proposal comes as popular backlash against data centers has reached a fever pitch, and New Mexico Gov.-elect Deb Haaland prepares to pause new large-scale data centers in New Mexico, an order the project’s backers say won’t affect tribal land. It also comes as developers nationwide increasingly look to tribal land for data center projects as states and cities tighten restrictions, according to a recent States Newsroom report. A separate data center proposal near Page, Ariz., drew opposition this year from the Navajo Nation’s LeChee Chapter.

The Nenahnezad Chapter campus would sit just east of Morgan Lake near the coal-fired Four Corners Generating Station. A site map provided by the utility shows the data center would cover 200 of the nearly 600 acres.

Approval of the project by the full tribal council appears uncertain, as many delegates have expressed opposition publicly, and a tribal council committee voted last week to recommend against the development.

Navajo Tribal Utility Authority officials didn’t respond to requests for comment. Neither did the bill’s sponsor, tribal council Delegate Rickie Nez; co-sponsor Brenda Jesus; or Nenahnezad Chapter President Norman Begaye.

A map of an “energy park” proposed to be developed on the Navajo Nation that would include a data center facility, energy generation and manufacturing. Image courtesy of Navajo Tribal Utility Authority

‘Anchor financial tenant’

The data center proposal is a newer addition to a project that dates back years. When the Nenahnezad Chapter endorsed the initial project in 2022, its resolution supported solar power and energy storage, and made no mention of a data center. Backers now say the data center is what would make the rest of the project — and the promised jobs it could bring — financially possible, and Jacobsson said it has been discussed publicly with Navajo leaders “since at least 2025.”

“You cannot build the manufacturing itself without the data center, and you cannot build the [high-performance] data center without the manufacturing,” said Arash Moalemi, a consultant for the tribal utility, at a Nov. 12 hearing before the Naabik’iyati Committee of the Navajo Nation Council.

“We have to have a data center as kind of an anchor financial tenant for that project,” he added.

After a nearly four-hour debate, the Naabik’iyati Committee rejected the proposal. Many delegates raised alarm about water use and several said it the proposal was rushed through with insufficient public input. Council delegates on the committee voted 4-12 against the lease, with seven not voting.

The public comment period on the project was open for just five days earlier this month, closing Nov. 11.

In a letter submitted the day after the public comment window closed, Violet White of the Navajo Nation’s Leupp Chapter called the five-day period “an insult to the grassroots people of the Navajo Nation.”

“Most of our elders and families on the land are not sitting online checking legislative portals every day and you know that,” White wrote. “Rushing a nearly 600-acre industrial lease through in five days is not public consultation. It is a deliberate effort to silence the people before they even know what is being taken.”

Rickie Nez, the sponsor, touted the project’s economic benefits for the region.

“This project very much will generate revenue for the nation,” Nez said at the hearing, adding it has the “communities in our area supporting it.”

Developers have promised thousands of construction jobs and thousands more full-time jobs at the “energy park.”

Moalemi said at “full build-out” the project has the “potential” to provide 4,300 to 4,750 full-time jobs, primarily for the manufacturing of energy products like solar cells and modules.

Delegate Titus Nez told utility representatives he supports the jobs but not the water use.

“I do support bringing jobs to the Navajo Nation for our people. But what I don’t support is you utilizing our scarce resource, the water,” Titus Nez said at the hearing. “We pray to have water for our people because water is life.”

Way to fund water project”?

One of the largest concerns from residents center on water use.

Developers have projected use of about 2.5 million gallons of water per day at the campus, according to Moalemi’s statements at the hearing.

Some residents have criticized the idea of bringing in “water-hungry” facilities like data centers and natural gas-fired power generation, pointing out many households on the Navajo Nation lack running water.

Jacobsson noted the manufacturing plant would be the heaviest water user, accounting for about 5% to 7% of the utility’s water rights. The data center would use up to 2%, followed by the power generation facilities and other site uses, he said.

Developers have cast the project as a way to help pay for a water infrastructure project that is expected to start delivering more water to the region in the coming years.

Moalemi argued during last week’s meeting the New Mexico side of the Navajo Nation has a “plethora” of water available for such projects; he pointed to the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project, a federal infrastructure project designed to deliver fresh water from the San Juan River to communities in the eastern part of the Navajo Nation. Deliveries from the pipeline are expected in late 2028, according to statements from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.

“Someone has to pay the operation, maintenance, and replacement of that cost,” he said of the infrastructure project. “Who can pay that? If we don’t bring projects like this onto the Navajo Nation — the New Mexico side — it’s going to be our ratepayers. That’s just how the utility world works.”

Jacobsson also cast the project as a way to offset the pipeline’s cost and “keep affordable water for the surrounding communities.”

Developers have indicated they plan to build a “closed-loop” cooling system for the planned data center, a design that has been touted as a way to reduce water use. Critics have noted, however, there is no requirement for a closed-loop system — or any cap on water use — in the current proposal.

The data center is expected to require about 700 megawatts of power, Jacobsson said, adding it would use power generated on site and deliver “subsidized” power to the utility’s customers; 700 megawatts is enough to power hundreds of thousands of homes.

Many questions ‘unanswered’

Most of the committee members voiced skepticism over the project.

Delegate Eugenia Charles-Newton said most Navajos are concerned about data centers.

“I feel like right off the bat we’re being cheated with what you guys are wanting to pay for such a huge industrial project,” she said at the hearing, adding, “We don’t want data centers because it’s going to suck up our water.”

Delegate Shawna Ann Claw said the proposed measure “does seem like it was fast-tracked without enough community consultation.”

Delegate Nathan Notah noted there are “just so many questions that are unanswered,” including “will it benefit the Navajo families or is it going to go out to outside customers?”

The only written comment in support of the proposal came from officials of the neighboring San Juan Chapter, who wrote the development “will bring monumental opportunities to the local communities” and introduce a “diverse industrial ecosystem.”

Daniel Tso — a former Navajo Nation Council delegate and environmental advocate — said in a phone interview this week he believes there is a good chance the project will be rejected by the full council, if those who have already voted against it do so again.

Tso signed a letter, along with another former tribal council delegate and a former Navajo Nation Supreme Court justice, urging officials to reject the lease without components like a performance bond. The current proposed lease includes a waiver for a performance bond.

The former Navajo officials wrote the project appears to be structured like a “standard private equity and hedge fund project.”

“The outside finance sponsor is normally the entity pushing to finalize financing regardless of risk, since that sponsor normally extracts its profit upfront the moment a lease is signed and debt is syndicated,” they wrote. “The risk framework would leave NTUA and the Navajo Nation holding the bag and bearing all the risk if the project stalls or defaults.”

Lion Point Capital Chief Investment Officer Didric Cederholm said in a statement late Wednesday “that is not how the deal is structured.” The tribal utility authority and NGI, its for-profit subsidiary, “are not required to put capital into the joint venture. The capital for the plant and the generation, more than $1 billion for the plant alone, comes from institutional investors outside the Nation, and they carry the construction and operating risk. Neither the Nation nor NTUA guarantees the project’s debt.”

He added, “The land stays with the Nation and is leased to NTUA, which approves every sublease, and the Nation is paid lease rent and taxes.”

Regarding the performance bond, he said, “The obligation sits one level down, with the companies that would build and operate on the site: the lease requires NTUA to obtain a performance bond from its sublessee, with the Navajo Nation as a covered party, and the sublease applies the bond requirement in Navajo law. … We will comply with that requirement, so the Nation is protected if a project ever ends.”

Gov.-elect Haaland has committed to signing an executive order her first day in office, pausing large-scale data center development while the Legislature develops guardrails.

At last week’s hearing, though, Moalemi said the tribal utility authority had researched the issue and found the moratorium “doesn’t apply” because of tribal sovereignty.

“We’re able to develop as long as we have authority and approval from the Navajo Nation,” he said.

Hannah Menchhoff, a spokesperson for Haaland, said in a statement she “always has and always will support tribal sovereignty and self-determination, and she looks forward to collaborative conversations with Tribes on a variety of issues, including data centers, as we work together to protect our water, land, and air.”

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Leave a comment